Riflessioni (a freddo) sul referendum (e un'ipotesi "accademica" di sostituzione dell'articolo 75) The catastrophic outcome of the referendum of 21-22 June sat only proves one thing. That party politics has on the side of the knife handle and does not intend to let go. Scilla (Italy), June 25, 2009
When a referendum does not reach the quorum everyone feels entitled to give the expression of will of elettori qualsiasi significato. Ed il suo contrario. Nel '99, ad esempio, per un soffio e - soprattutto - per cavilli sui quali ci sarebbe ancor oggi da indagare in merito al calcolo effettivo degli elettori sui quali stabilire la metà più uno di essi, il quorum non venne raggiunto. Del quasi cinquanta per cento di elettori che votarono, comunque, una maggioranza schiacciante si espresse per una trasformazione della legge elettorale di allora che abolisse la "quota proporzionale" e rendesse il sistema esclusivamente maggioritario, uninominale, a turno unico. Ebbene: più di una faccia tosta ebbe a dire che gl'Italiani s'erano chiaramente espressi per un ritorno al sistema proporzionale!
Molta acqua è passata sotto i ponti da allora. Nel Meanwhile, the desire to return to the proportional policy of the house had never been dormant in the majority of the Italian ruling class, who had reluctantly accepted neck introduce a little 'electoral principles of Anglo-Saxon in our system, to the benefit of reducing party fragmentation, the direct participation of the voter to choose the government, the relative stability of the term of office of President of the Council, with the consequent increase in the continuity, consistency and effectiveness of governmental programming ... The proportionality wisely instilled in the minds of Berlusconi by Giuliano Urbani since 1993, slowly preparing the his revenge. It was the autumn of 2005, a period of particular difficulty for the center- then that the government was desperate to be able to stay even after the elections next spring that would mark the return of broken while Prodi at Palazzo Chigi . With the leaves and the rain fell from the sky even the law Calderoli . The porcellum - according to the passion of Latin maccheronica prof. Sartori - or a nasty , according to the directness of his own valley proposer. Ie an inextricable jumble of lists, coalitions, electoral threshold is different depending on whether or not part of a coalition or coalition that reaches some other threshold that is created to it ... Coalitions that could not come to train with the pensioners of the left and right, the popular ecologists and those socialists, separatists and those bossiani antibossiani , the to Craxi Stefania Craxi and to Bobo , the beds at Gianni Letta and the Henry ... And then the break-even in 2006 ( twenty-four thousand votes difference between the Union prodiana and Berlusconi's Casa delle Libertà ) and the subsequent formation of a majority in armata Brancaleone style that was more in the Senate nothing short of reckless ... Watching this
framework, the genius of the constitutional Messina Giovanni Guzzetta will get moving again, and only thing that can happen to the genes in this mess could to catch a glimpse - well aware, in accordance with article 75 of the Constitution, can only use the whitebait and not even a pen - an electoral system that could have caused the transformation of the political system in a bipolar trend bipartisan way, giving goodbye forever - at the same time - with the parties to a point six per cent that could give the Minister of Justice or a hundred thousand-odd votes were rewarded with a place to Deputy Minister at the Foreign Ministry ...
E 'here come the three referendum questions, whose campaign collection of signatures already ended in the summer of 2007 and were admitted by the Constitutional Court in January. And 'the referendum initiative to contribute to the acceleration of the dynamics already in place. The "next time, we run on our own" announced in a very unexpected yet the previous 2008 elections by the Democratic Party first secretary of the then infant Veltroni. And most importantly, leaving the majority of Mastella, which caused immediate judicial investigation that involved the companion of life and politics Sandra Lonardo , actually smoldered for some time because of the triple referendum Guzzetta that sounded like a real bugbear for parties microbial and blackmailers.
Mastella had miscalculated, and found himself jobless and homeless. Caused the dissolution of the automatic suspension of the referendum procedure already opened, as hoped, in fact, Mastella and the other dwarves. But Veltroni held firm - while allowing a derogation of the values \u200b\u200bto Italy - and showed that the "run themselves" was not a bluff . Berlusconi took the attitude veltroni the courage to make the largest national section of the European People's Party. The referendum Guzzetta, so, without being held, also produced most of its effects, as for parties excluded from its alliance with one of the two major ports of the national parliament would remain barred if they had received at least four percent in Tutt 'Italy in the House or eight per cent in at least one region the Senate. What happened to just ' Casini's UDC and the controversial former president of the Sicilian Cuffaro.
Hence the impression of a loss of necessity and urgency of "electoral reform by referendum." But it was not that of an impression. The term of the old system, in fact, allowed exemptions for DiPietro bossiani and that gave us two strong parties in medium to large degree of imbalance the policy of the two major parties. In the opposite direction to any reform of the judiciary - IDV against Pd - or to an almost complete deafness to the needs of economic and infrastructure development in the South and the Islands, the Northern League against the PDL . Not to mention that the Democratic Party will again present its very difficult race semisolitaria given top priority to regain the majority even if it means endangering the cohesion and consistency of the future structure of government, and that the people of freedom can not not react the same way the multiplication of the list to the other front. The failure the referendum will not force policy to turn back. But the risk is there and is very strong and may soon become irresistible ...
this outcome was made possible by the antidotes that party politics has always successfully devised to defuse any possibility of real democratization of decision-making. He waited more than two decades before we achieve the law that would allow the implementation of Article 75. It does not pay, has sown here and there the devices that would make it essentially useless. For example absurd slip by one year the planned referendum in the event of dissolution of Parliament. By what logic? If you follow the logic, there would be no more consistent be expressed in the same day on the choice of legislators and the address to be given to legislation in at least one subject.
The absence, then, rules prohibiting the Parliament to legislate to the contrary to the will of the referendum for a number of years, or do so only on condition of seeking the opinion of the people - and this time without a quorum - has enabled a number cases of alarming safely ignore the response of the polls. Look Tutt 'merely secondary in determining the disaffection of many Italians for the institute.
are necessary to institute changes. The policy will not because they are not interested. And since not even have the courage to abolish once and for all this blessed 75, you will only hope in a growing awareness of the importance of voters of each individual appointment with the ballot.
must raise the required number of signatures to demand a referendum, given the ease of collecting much larger than in 1947 granted by modern means of communication and transport. We must lower the quorum because it is true that its cancellation would dry formally possible to highly organized minority to impose their will on the whole nation, it is also true that you can not force people to have an interest in things against which do not test at all nor is it right that those opposed to the repeal facciano blocco con i puri e semplici indifferenti, facendo sì che il loro non voto assuma un valore almeno doppio rispetto a quello di chi va a votare e vota sì. Bisogna concedere alle leggi del Parlamento ed agli altri atti legislativi un periodo di vita che le protegga da modifiche immediate e le faccia valutare nella pienezza dei loro effetti e dei loro limiti. Bisogna far sì che la data del referendum sia ben determinata e che non sia in balia delle esigenze e dei capricci della partitocrazia...
E così, per puro divertimento estivo, ho provato a rispondere a queste esigenze nella fantascientifica proposta di revisione dell'articolo 75 nel modo seguente:
È indetto referendum popolare per deliberare l'abrogazione, all or part of a law or an act having the force of law, in force for at least six years, when requested by a million voters, or one third of the regional councils. The six-year term does not refer to the modifications and additions have taken on an existing text. The request for partial withdrawal may not affect a part of the legislative text of less than an entire article or, for articles composed of more than four paragraphs, to an entire paragraph.
There shall be no referendum on the law of tax, budget, amnesty and pardon, the ratification of international treaties.
have the right to participate in the referendum all citizens eligible to vote for the Chamber of Deputies.
The deadline for signature collection or the deliberations of the regional councils need not exceed three months. The referendum takes place the second Sunday in May, when the perfection of the request was held before December 31 preceding, or if the second Sunday in November took place before June 30 of that year.
The proposal was approved subject to a referendum if they participated in the vote two-fifths of claimants, and if it reaches the majority of the valid votes cast.
Nei sei anni dallo svolgimento del referendum, non possono essere adottate ai sensi degli articoli 70, 76 o 77 modifiche od integrazioni ad una legge o ad un atto avente valore di legge che vadano in senso contrario a quello espresso dalla votazione, in caso sia di accoglimento sia di diniego della proposta, che sia valida ai sensi del precedente comma. Durante il predetto termine, il comitato promotore del referendum o quello per il voto contrario, costituiti secondo la legge, o, per i referendum proposti da Consigli regionali, il Presidente di una Giunta o di un Consiglio regionale, anche di Regioni diverse da quelle i cui Consigli hanno promosso il referendum, possono promuovere davanti alla Corte costituzionale la sospensione degli effetti e la questione di legittimità di una legge o di un atto avente valore di legge che abbia introdotto modifiche o integrazioni che vadano in senso contrario a quello espresso dalla votazione. Nel periodo compreso tra il sesto ed il quindicesimo anno successivo alla votazione valida, gli stessi soggetti, senza ulteriori raccolte di firme o deliberazioni di Consigli regionali, possono promuovere l'abrogazione, mediante referendum, delle modifiche ed integrazioni adottate dal Parlamento o dal Governo in senso contrario a quello espresso dalla votazione. La proposta soggetta a referendum è approvata se è raggiunta la maggioranza dei voti validamente espressi.
La legge determina le modalità di attuazione del referendum.
John Panuccio
giovannipanuccio.blog @ gmail.com